Free shipping on $45+, or pick up in-store
Earn FREE points for faster Cash Back Awards. This Month's Secret Code is SUNNYDAY

Candy, Cookies & Pastries by My Cookie Dealer

Fuel your muscles and satisfy your cravings with delicious protein cookies in all your favorite flavors.
Pickup & Delivery Availability
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Bite Sized Protein Cookies - 25g Protein - Chocolate Chip (5 Ounce Bag)
(10)
$4.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Pick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Toaster Pastry - 20g Protein - Frosted Strawberry (12 Servings)
(3)
$45.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Free ShippingiPick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Toaster Pastry - 20g Protein - Powdered Raspberry Donut (12 Pack)
Be the First to Review
$45.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Free ShippingiPick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Cookie - 15g Protein - Milk & Cookies (12 Cookies)
(1)
$40.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Pick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Cookie - 15g Protein - Chocolate Candy Ganache (12 Cookies)
(3)
$40.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Pick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Toaster Pastry - 20g Protein - Frosted Apple Pie (12 Servings)
(2)
$45.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Free ShippingiPick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Bite Sized Protein Cookies - 25g Protein - Milk & Cookies (5 Ounce Bag)
(5)
$4.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Pick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Toaster Pastry - 20g Protein - Frosted Blueberry (12 Servings)
(3)
$45.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Free ShippingiPick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Toaster Pastry - 20g Protein - Frosted Chocolate Donut (12 Servings)
Be the First to Review
$45.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Free ShippingiPick-Up
add ed  to Cart

BOGO

 Buy One, Get One 50% Off i
Protein Cookie - 15g Protein - Strawberry Toaster Pastry (12 Cookies)
(3)
$40.99

Same-Day Delivery. Order by 2PM.

Pick-Up
add ed  to Cart
back to top
Looking For More?
Related Products
  • Axe and Sledge
    Farm Fed Whey Protein Isolate Protein Powder - Brown Cinnamon Toaster Pastry (25 Servings)
    Farm Fed Whey Protein Isolate Protein Powder -
    Farm Fed is a premium-quality 100% grass-fed whey protein isolate designed to fuel recovery, muscle growth, and real results. No gimmicks. No junk. Just clean, fast-digesting protein that works as hard as you do. This isn’t your average protein powder. We sourced grass-fed whey isolate for superior purity, better absorption, and a complete amino acid profile — including naturally high levels of leucine for optimal muscle protein synthesis. Plus, we added DigeSEB digestive enzymes so you can say goodbye to the bloating and gas that comes with cheap, underdosed proteins.
    Rated 4 stars out of 5 stars, From 5 customer reviews
    $59.99
    Add To Cart
  • Built Brands, LLC
    Built Puff Protein Bar - 17g Protein - Cookies 'N Cream (12 Bars)
    Built Puff Protein Bar - 17g Protein -
    We are all made of protein. That's why we created the best tasting protein ever. Built. To Literally Built & Power you from head to toe. Built is the best protein bar you'll ever have, and will help you become the best version of you. Benefits of Protein: Maximizes your marvelous mind, creates strong & healthy hair, supports silkier, smoother skin, fuels an all around beautiful body, and promotes muscle growth. In closing, Built Protein can help you strong and healthy. And since your body needs protein every single day, make it the best tasting protein ever. Built.
    Rated 3 stars out of 5 stars, From 3 customer reviews
    $32.99
    Add To Cart
  • Legendary Foods
    Protein Sweet Roll - 20g Protein - Caramel Sticky Bun (8 Rolls)
    Protein Sweet Roll - 20g Protein - Caramel
    Protein for snack food junkies. Bored of protein bars? So are we. That's why we made a decadent sticky bun with rich caramel and a touch of cinnamon. Each roll is packed with 20gm protein and only 1gm sugar, so you can enjoy every bite, guilt-free.
    Rated 5 stars out of 5 stars, From 2 customer reviews
    $27.99
    Add To Cart
  • Transparent Labs
    100% Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate Powder – Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie (2.28 lbs./30 Servings)
    100% Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate Powder – Oatmeal
    • Supports muscle growth and recovery
    • Informed Choice and Informed Protein certified
    • Non-GMO
    • Free of gluten, artificial sweeteners, food dyes, fillers, and preservatives
    • Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie flavor

    Transparent Labs 100% Grass-Fed Whey Protein Isolate supports muscle growth, post-workout recovery, and healthy body composition.

    Each serving delivers 28g of high-quality whey protein isolate sourced from 100% grass-fed cattle that are humanely raised and never treated with growth hormones or hormonal agents.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    What is whey protein isolate?

    Whey protein isolate (WPI) has the highest concentration of protein and BCAAs, while having less carbs, cholesterol, and fat compared to other whey proteins. WPI is also low in lactose and easy on your digestive tract.

    Rated 5 stars out of 5 stars, From 4786 customer reviews
    $59.99
    Add To Cart
Related Searches

Find Cookies & Pastries by My Cookie Dealer at The Vitamin Shoppe Store Near You

There are more than 600 The Vitamin Shoppe® stores across the US, so it's very likely you can pop in and find Cookies & Pastries by My Cookie Dealer locally. Check out our store locator to find a Shoppe near you. Don’t forget—you’ll save at least 15% on every subscription with Auto Delivery, plus an addition 5% off select brands to help you stay on the path. Not only will you never miss a thing, but you’ll also get free shipping on subscription refills of $25 or more!* You define what better looks (and feels) like—Count on us to help you get there.


Shipping & Returns

  • FREE for Orders over $45

    Orders under $45, domestic shipping is only $7.99. Find more at our Shipping Policy page.

    • Return Policy for Items Purchased Online

    Shop with confidence with our Easy Returns Policy. Customers may return any opened or unopened merchandise purchased from any Vitamin Shoppe channel to any Vitamin Shoppe store within 30 days. Find more at our full Returns Policy page.

Need More Help?

Chat with one of our Health Enthusiasts right now.

LIVE CHAT
HomeFood & DrinksFoodsCookies & Pastries
Page loadingLOADING...
Page loadingLOADING...